Pomegranate logoPomegranate

· The Pomegranate team · 6 min read

Dante vs MADI: which should you use for live sound?

Dante and MADI compared for live audio: cabling, channel counts, routing, latency, redundancy, clocking and cost, plus which to pick for a plugin computer.

RME Digiface Dante beside an RME MADIface USB
Product images: RME

MADI and Dante both move dozens of channels of digital audio on very little cable. They solve the problem in different ways, and the right choice depends on what you're connecting.

The short version

  • MADI is a point-to-point cable. One link carries 64 channels at 48 kHz from one device to another. Nothing to configure, nothing in between.
  • Dante is a network. Every device plugs into Ethernet switches, and any channel can go to any device, set up in software.

Side by side

MADIDante
Cable75-ohm coax (BNC) or optical fiber (SC)Standard Ethernet, through switches
Channels64 at 48 kHz, 32 at 96 kHz, per linkSet by each device; the network carries far more
DistanceAbout 100 m coax, about 2 km optical (per RME)Ethernet distances between switches; fiber for longer runs
RoutingFixed links; route inside the devicesAny to any, in Dante Controller
LatencyDirect link, no network1 ms default device latency, down to 150 µs
RedundancyDual inputs with automatic failover on many devicesSecondary network on a second port
ClockWord clock, or recovered from the MADI signalPTP over the network
ComputerNeeds a MADI interfaceDante Virtual Soundcard (software) or a Dante interface

When MADI makes more sense

  • Linking two things. Console to plugin computer, console to recorder, stage to front of house. A MADI pair is simple and hard to get wrong.
  • You want no network. No switches to configure, no IP addresses, no QoS settings.
  • Your console already has it. Many touring consoles ship with MADI ports or common MADI cards.
Console sends channels over MADI to an interface; Pomegranate processes them and returns them to the consoleConsoleMADI card or portMADI interfaceUSB, PCIe or ThunderboltPomegranateplugins on every channelMADI outMADI inASIO / Core AudioprocessedOne coax or optical pair carries up to 64 channels each way
MADI: one point-to-point link each way.

When Dante makes more sense

  • Many devices sharing audio. Stage boxes, FOH and monitor consoles, a recorder and a broadcast feed can all see the same inputs.
  • Flexible routing. Changing a route is a click in Dante Controller, not a cable change.
  • Installed systems, where the venue's network infrastructure is already in place.
A Dante network: stage box, console, recorder and a plugin computer all connected to one Ethernet switchGigabit switchQoS on, EEE offStage boxmic preampsConsoleDante card or built inRecordermultitrack PCPlugin computerDante Virtual Soundcard or PCIeEvery device sees every other device.Routing is done in Dante Controller.
Dante: a network where every device can reach every other.

For a plugin computer

For a computer running plugins on a show, the transport matters less than the audio interface and its driver. What decides the latency you get is the buffer size the computer can run reliably, plus the interface's converter and driver overhead. See latency in live sound.

With MADI you'll use a hardware MADI interface; our guide to RME MADI interfaces covers the main options. With Dante you can start with Dante Virtual Soundcard, which is cheap but starts at 4 ms of buffering, or use a hardware Dante interface for lower latency.

Frequently asked questions

Is Dante replacing MADI?

Dante is growing fast, but MADI is still built into or available for most professional consoles and is widely used for point-to-point links. Many rigs use both, with converters between them.

Which has lower latency, Dante or MADI?

Both can be very low. Dante hardware defaults to 1 ms device latency and can go down to 150 µs. MADI is a direct point-to-point link with no network in between. For a plugin computer, the audio interface and buffer size usually matter more than the transport.

Can I convert between Dante and MADI?

Yes. Several devices bridge the two, for example RME's Digiface Dante, which has Dante and MADI ports and can run as a stand-alone converter.